{
  "format": "postrun_cause_classification_sidecar",
  "original_numeric_scores_unchanged": true,
  "original_unclassified_error_count": 21,
  "audited_rows": 21,
  "audited_error_class_counts": {
    "semantic": 11,
    "permission": 10
  },
  "all_task_error_attribution_counts": {
    "product": 161,
    "fixture": 0,
    "environment": 0,
    "unresolved": 0
  },
  "all_task_error_cause_counts": {
    "federated_join_key_missing": 11,
    "planner_no_usable_leg_sql": 123,
    "generated_schema_reference": 14,
    "generated_missing_schema_qualification": 10,
    "generation_no_usable_query": 2,
    "generated_function_type_mismatch": 1
  },
  "first_turn_errors_unchanged": 60,
  "first_turn_errors_product_caused": 60,
  "later_turn_unresolved_cause_resolved": 1,
  "runtime_classification_target_passed": false,
  "runtime_classification_limit": "A postrun audit does not fix the original runtime or change its scored 21 unclassified errors. The original baseline remains failed on that acceptance target.",
  "refusal_policy": "Missing generated merge keys do not establish that a supported question is unanswerable. No justified-refusal or correct-answer credit is added.",
  "held_question_sql_expected_value_release": false,
  "raw_private_sha256": {
    "attempts": "efd47bb5eac3ca42aac3acb9c1529848049711a56af3bc81862562f1bbff2a1f",
    "summary": "394507cc3772d2b008832cbfe9c95cc74252851ec0dd66f50f71f2c1b5287e51",
    "server_log": "d9f2772c271a4859bba4a76ea4d2bfb26fa8f760ee43ca23556e2a5d7cfb0af8"
  },
  "rows": [
    {
      "case_id": "8722731a33243cfe",
      "evidence_reference": "e5-original-attempt-record:2",
      "original_outcome": "task_error",
      "original_terminal_error_class": null,
      "original_outward_error_class": "sql",
      "original_classification_verified": false,
      "audited_error_class": "semantic",
      "audited_cause_category": "federated_join_key_missing",
      "audited_attribution": "product",
      "exception_type": "FederatedGoldUnavailableError",
      "source_sql_sha256": [
        "28570f00afdef817ced5fa06762534011afeafa01db91c4aa5d62a8dc42c2b32",
        "6931c11eb18d1acfcffd5780ae9ba8cfe7c3ed1279d21ab70eb03a25c8ec84f4"
      ],
      "evidence_basis": "The selected failing merge source has no user_id output. The question requires an answer; generated input is incomplete. This is a semantic generation contract failure, not an independently justified refusal.",
      "server_log_lines": null,
      "score_changed": false,
      "refusal_credit_added": false
    },
    {
      "case_id": "6f24c1f6a5a6d89c",
      "evidence_reference": "e5-original-attempt-record:8",
      "original_outcome": "task_error",
      "original_terminal_error_class": null,
      "original_outward_error_class": "sql",
      "original_classification_verified": false,
      "audited_error_class": "semantic",
      "audited_cause_category": "federated_join_key_missing",
      "audited_attribution": "product",
      "exception_type": "FederatedCtUnavailableError",
      "source_sql_sha256": [
        "340aff85547bbeecb0765f6a0834881b2bd9dae12e8ad407d561719e7f6e5b0b",
        "f1c0714724bbde29c2dcb0dfc2191797fe6dbf2ffdf630634ae3cbb58be03e05"
      ],
      "evidence_basis": "The selected failing merge source has no user_id output. The question requires an answer; generated input is incomplete. This is a semantic generation contract failure, not an independently justified refusal.",
      "server_log_lines": null,
      "score_changed": false,
      "refusal_credit_added": false
    },
    {
      "case_id": "8c8bbb233ff1ce51",
      "evidence_reference": "e5-original-attempt-record:30",
      "original_outcome": "task_error",
      "original_terminal_error_class": null,
      "original_outward_error_class": "sql",
      "original_classification_verified": false,
      "audited_error_class": "semantic",
      "audited_cause_category": "federated_join_key_missing",
      "audited_attribution": "product",
      "exception_type": "FederatedCtUnavailableError",
      "source_sql_sha256": [
        "ce0d30d94b91d697202bedf7d395aea077ba430a2e6d74114169c2f3f5dcd4f3",
        "a0fe56de4c8951148835a6b025324985dcdf33ee80437586dea8ad10fd7cc78c"
      ],
      "evidence_basis": "The selected failing merge source has no user_id output. The question requires an answer; generated input is incomplete. This is a semantic generation contract failure, not an independently justified refusal.",
      "server_log_lines": null,
      "score_changed": false,
      "refusal_credit_added": false
    },
    {
      "case_id": "4e156f98a1c0bb7d",
      "evidence_reference": "e5-original-attempt-record:36",
      "original_outcome": "task_error",
      "original_terminal_error_class": null,
      "original_outward_error_class": "sql",
      "original_classification_verified": false,
      "audited_error_class": "semantic",
      "audited_cause_category": "federated_join_key_missing",
      "audited_attribution": "product",
      "exception_type": "FederatedCtUnavailableError",
      "source_sql_sha256": [
        "4e4da4677322a6949f588f58ca2478eb2a90524ee295475e95e6921d09a93eda",
        "177b28b0d2fee66f90bd39d99bbb4f1e57466c716bc9954ed02dd793bc4a6252"
      ],
      "evidence_basis": "The selected failing merge source has no user_id output. The question requires an answer; generated input is incomplete. This is a semantic generation contract failure, not an independently justified refusal.",
      "server_log_lines": null,
      "score_changed": false,
      "refusal_credit_added": false
    },
    {
      "case_id": "2dd994c5d2d4fc76",
      "evidence_reference": "e5-original-attempt-record:38",
      "original_outcome": "task_error",
      "original_terminal_error_class": null,
      "original_outward_error_class": "sql",
      "original_classification_verified": false,
      "audited_error_class": "semantic",
      "audited_cause_category": "federated_join_key_missing",
      "audited_attribution": "product",
      "exception_type": "FederatedGoldUnavailableError",
      "source_sql_sha256": [
        "c93306e6360b89c5dbc809a5095e90352d17a4dbc7b46756eb1db0567fb7631e",
        "cad2099537f8e32d0a64310060bafb0b3dffb3ccd6c8f2e426c9aee4dcd0e35e"
      ],
      "evidence_basis": "The selected failing merge source has no user_id output. The question requires an answer; generated input is incomplete. This is a semantic generation contract failure, not an independently justified refusal.",
      "server_log_lines": null,
      "score_changed": false,
      "refusal_credit_added": false
    },
    {
      "case_id": "6a4b6a9bdf94b7bb",
      "evidence_reference": "e5-original-attempt-record:42",
      "original_outcome": "task_error",
      "original_terminal_error_class": null,
      "original_outward_error_class": "sql",
      "original_classification_verified": false,
      "audited_error_class": "semantic",
      "audited_cause_category": "federated_join_key_missing",
      "audited_attribution": "product",
      "exception_type": "FederatedGoldUnavailableError",
      "source_sql_sha256": [
        "e90a0e61d8024d2b0786cba7284a1c82e62e07d2038efc728acfeb17217d41a5",
        "cd7d655a8d7509746bf08cd3c8143a56dfc01845340ec7adfe9fefdf70a5bf83"
      ],
      "evidence_basis": "The selected failing merge source has no user_id output. The question requires an answer; generated input is incomplete. This is a semantic generation contract failure, not an independently justified refusal.",
      "server_log_lines": null,
      "score_changed": false,
      "refusal_credit_added": false
    },
    {
      "case_id": "43d4c8ff241da313",
      "evidence_reference": "e5-original-attempt-record:47",
      "original_outcome": "task_error",
      "original_terminal_error_class": null,
      "original_outward_error_class": "sql",
      "original_classification_verified": false,
      "audited_error_class": "semantic",
      "audited_cause_category": "federated_join_key_missing",
      "audited_attribution": "product",
      "exception_type": "FederatedGoldUnavailableError",
      "source_sql_sha256": [
        "a6da360c2b11eac39839866c307f9c901ed9aa8eb513f9d2083efae082287b9e",
        "329284049fe70d167b58f828d0143dcd83535dd4b2cae71e024e9f8a941e78e9"
      ],
      "evidence_basis": "The selected failing merge source has no user_id output. The question requires an answer; generated input is incomplete. This is a semantic generation contract failure, not an independently justified refusal.",
      "server_log_lines": null,
      "score_changed": false,
      "refusal_credit_added": false
    },
    {
      "case_id": "f752b5c15bea18e2",
      "evidence_reference": "e5-original-attempt-record:49",
      "original_outcome": "task_error",
      "original_terminal_error_class": null,
      "original_outward_error_class": "sql",
      "original_classification_verified": false,
      "audited_error_class": "permission",
      "audited_cause_category": "generated_missing_schema_qualification",
      "audited_attribution": "product",
      "exception_type": null,
      "source_sql_sha256": [
        "3e6408140d913e5ff13fe9ee67734193e5176a24d79df9648831630b099d7182"
      ],
      "evidence_basis": "Generated SQL omits the authorized source schema. Validation resolves the physical relation to public and denies it under INV-BI-002. The correctly qualified authorized relation exists in the frozen fixture.",
      "server_log_lines": null,
      "score_changed": false,
      "refusal_credit_added": false
    },
    {
      "case_id": "487f39682668dd53",
      "evidence_reference": "e5-original-attempt-record:172",
      "original_outcome": "task_error",
      "original_terminal_error_class": null,
      "original_outward_error_class": "sql",
      "original_classification_verified": false,
      "audited_error_class": "semantic",
      "audited_cause_category": "federated_join_key_missing",
      "audited_attribution": "product",
      "exception_type": "FederatedCtUnavailableError",
      "source_sql_sha256": [
        "f9e8721f0d78030a0b8bdb8d7b24d6645b7c8a711570420abe8c882a71eb21cb",
        "941f04b383f8199d10d460331bfcfda9526c1e5f6c62fb17ae80db4e1f778be0"
      ],
      "evidence_basis": "The selected failing merge source has no user_id output. The question requires an answer; generated input is incomplete. This is a semantic generation contract failure, not an independently justified refusal.",
      "server_log_lines": null,
      "score_changed": false,
      "refusal_credit_added": false
    },
    {
      "case_id": "26a98324c1ddb333",
      "evidence_reference": "e5-original-attempt-record:174",
      "original_outcome": "task_error",
      "original_terminal_error_class": null,
      "original_outward_error_class": "sql",
      "original_classification_verified": false,
      "audited_error_class": "permission",
      "audited_cause_category": "generated_missing_schema_qualification",
      "audited_attribution": "product",
      "exception_type": null,
      "source_sql_sha256": [
        "c67d1393fa92b08af1e7c0bd9b4c05c5ef3d2c4136ac7c83c67536d07a217649"
      ],
      "evidence_basis": "Generated SQL omits the authorized source schema. Validation resolves the physical relation to public and denies it under INV-BI-002. The correctly qualified authorized relation exists in the frozen fixture.",
      "server_log_lines": null,
      "score_changed": false,
      "refusal_credit_added": false
    },
    {
      "case_id": "063ada8e5fd47478",
      "evidence_reference": "e5-original-attempt-record:179",
      "original_outcome": "task_error",
      "original_terminal_error_class": null,
      "original_outward_error_class": "sql",
      "original_classification_verified": false,
      "audited_error_class": "permission",
      "audited_cause_category": "generated_missing_schema_qualification",
      "audited_attribution": "product",
      "exception_type": null,
      "source_sql_sha256": [
        "73e43687ede3554d359b9777b4a9d80624455db9063b98e5601a53718064ba20"
      ],
      "evidence_basis": "Generated SQL omits the authorized source schema. Validation resolves the physical relation to public and denies it under INV-BI-002. The correctly qualified authorized relation exists in the frozen fixture.",
      "server_log_lines": null,
      "score_changed": false,
      "refusal_credit_added": false
    },
    {
      "case_id": "e4014f16268a11a4",
      "evidence_reference": "e5-original-attempt-record:183",
      "original_outcome": "task_error",
      "original_terminal_error_class": null,
      "original_outward_error_class": "sql",
      "original_classification_verified": false,
      "audited_error_class": "permission",
      "audited_cause_category": "generated_missing_schema_qualification",
      "audited_attribution": "product",
      "exception_type": null,
      "source_sql_sha256": [
        "62992ccd6bc4bb7a8057a2a9df472195ba2e2b8feda50e6cedabe128473bc50f"
      ],
      "evidence_basis": "Generated SQL omits the authorized source schema. Validation resolves the physical relation to public and denies it under INV-BI-002. The correctly qualified authorized relation exists in the frozen fixture.",
      "server_log_lines": null,
      "score_changed": false,
      "refusal_credit_added": false
    },
    {
      "case_id": "0443c4d059d87f4b",
      "evidence_reference": "e5-original-attempt-record:186",
      "original_outcome": "task_error",
      "original_terminal_error_class": null,
      "original_outward_error_class": "sql",
      "original_classification_verified": false,
      "audited_error_class": "permission",
      "audited_cause_category": "generated_missing_schema_qualification",
      "audited_attribution": "product",
      "exception_type": null,
      "source_sql_sha256": [
        "f447c28c6b217b4978fb9d8b98e0723df2b5609a7258e9c266b981847ae27a23"
      ],
      "evidence_basis": "Generated SQL omits the authorized source schema. Validation resolves the physical relation to public and denies it under INV-BI-002. The correctly qualified authorized relation exists in the frozen fixture.",
      "server_log_lines": null,
      "score_changed": false,
      "refusal_credit_added": false
    },
    {
      "case_id": "e5f1f7c2f64aa0d4",
      "evidence_reference": "e5-original-attempt-record:197",
      "original_outcome": "task_error",
      "original_terminal_error_class": null,
      "original_outward_error_class": "sql",
      "original_classification_verified": false,
      "audited_error_class": "permission",
      "audited_cause_category": "generated_missing_schema_qualification",
      "audited_attribution": "product",
      "exception_type": "FederatedGoldUnavailableError",
      "source_sql_sha256": [
        "d688820eb5e15a9c5f3a1ed073f04a9e12cbcbc8763661bfd91a3f1d20156ee4",
        "4161c85f6aee6972efb754de6cbf1ec004692cf5b149fbd830b61617cd7a1b5a"
      ],
      "evidence_basis": "Generated SQL omits the authorized source schema. Validation resolves the physical relation to public and denies it under INV-BI-002. The correctly qualified authorized relation exists in the frozen fixture.",
      "server_log_lines": [
        946,
        947
      ],
      "score_changed": false,
      "refusal_credit_added": false
    },
    {
      "case_id": "1f873188e50f9834",
      "evidence_reference": "e5-original-attempt-record:200",
      "original_outcome": "task_error",
      "original_terminal_error_class": null,
      "original_outward_error_class": "sql",
      "original_classification_verified": false,
      "audited_error_class": "semantic",
      "audited_cause_category": "federated_join_key_missing",
      "audited_attribution": "product",
      "exception_type": "FederatedCtUnavailableError",
      "source_sql_sha256": [
        "f9e8721f0d78030a0b8bdb8d7b24d6645b7c8a711570420abe8c882a71eb21cb",
        "2521ce3fd716687b9129532490e98a94717f4c69897d35856c82c8447173c932"
      ],
      "evidence_basis": "The selected failing merge source has no user_id output. The question requires an answer; generated input is incomplete. This is a semantic generation contract failure, not an independently justified refusal.",
      "server_log_lines": null,
      "score_changed": false,
      "refusal_credit_added": false
    },
    {
      "case_id": "16eec6f9b6bab050",
      "evidence_reference": "e5-original-attempt-record:214",
      "original_outcome": "task_error",
      "original_terminal_error_class": null,
      "original_outward_error_class": "sql",
      "original_classification_verified": false,
      "audited_error_class": "semantic",
      "audited_cause_category": "federated_join_key_missing",
      "audited_attribution": "product",
      "exception_type": "FederatedGoldUnavailableError",
      "source_sql_sha256": [
        "ca68adacadb6b82aeb9c01b021356a254cf5a43d269a95c9c87a20ca1184a3a0",
        "9bfa82294fe43eff0df9d7a8a64b1a2c622477412b56c74974f787476fda8ffb"
      ],
      "evidence_basis": "The selected failing merge source has no user_id output. The question requires an answer; generated input is incomplete. This is a semantic generation contract failure, not an independently justified refusal.",
      "server_log_lines": null,
      "score_changed": false,
      "refusal_credit_added": false
    },
    {
      "case_id": "90f4a17bed1f391d",
      "evidence_reference": "e5-original-attempt-record:216",
      "original_outcome": "task_error",
      "original_terminal_error_class": null,
      "original_outward_error_class": "sql",
      "original_classification_verified": false,
      "audited_error_class": "permission",
      "audited_cause_category": "generated_missing_schema_qualification",
      "audited_attribution": "product",
      "exception_type": null,
      "source_sql_sha256": [
        "bbdd73470013058140a8886c56532033d12cd80cd9e4bab2750ce83c9b61defa"
      ],
      "evidence_basis": "Generated SQL omits the authorized source schema. Validation resolves the physical relation to public and denies it under INV-BI-002. The correctly qualified authorized relation exists in the frozen fixture.",
      "server_log_lines": null,
      "score_changed": false,
      "refusal_credit_added": false
    },
    {
      "case_id": "a3f7ce100d85812c",
      "evidence_reference": "e5-original-attempt-record:217",
      "original_outcome": "task_error",
      "original_terminal_error_class": null,
      "original_outward_error_class": "sql",
      "original_classification_verified": false,
      "audited_error_class": "semantic",
      "audited_cause_category": "federated_join_key_missing",
      "audited_attribution": "product",
      "exception_type": "FederatedCtUnavailableError",
      "source_sql_sha256": [
        "2338f40cec2dcbccaf847e417442fb7801172619baf22f6412ed7431cb3003f0",
        "bab461b7e86618a35a7e9ec2b4b99918386675862ec0d7d2a6ba8034a8a95b6c"
      ],
      "evidence_basis": "The selected failing merge source has no user_id output. The question requires an answer; generated input is incomplete. This is a semantic generation contract failure, not an independently justified refusal.",
      "server_log_lines": null,
      "score_changed": false,
      "refusal_credit_added": false
    },
    {
      "case_id": "4978d8cfcc8651d4",
      "evidence_reference": "e5-original-attempt-record:220",
      "original_outcome": "task_error",
      "original_terminal_error_class": null,
      "original_outward_error_class": "sql",
      "original_classification_verified": false,
      "audited_error_class": "permission",
      "audited_cause_category": "generated_missing_schema_qualification",
      "audited_attribution": "product",
      "exception_type": null,
      "source_sql_sha256": [
        "2f0abda1f90846571a2cda89ab0b5fc9c0b96be2552f718295085f16559f760a"
      ],
      "evidence_basis": "Generated SQL omits the authorized source schema. Validation resolves the physical relation to public and denies it under INV-BI-002. The correctly qualified authorized relation exists in the frozen fixture.",
      "server_log_lines": null,
      "score_changed": false,
      "refusal_credit_added": false
    },
    {
      "case_id": "a294192244c4d103",
      "evidence_reference": "e5-original-attempt-record:224",
      "original_outcome": "task_error",
      "original_terminal_error_class": null,
      "original_outward_error_class": "sql",
      "original_classification_verified": false,
      "audited_error_class": "permission",
      "audited_cause_category": "generated_missing_schema_qualification",
      "audited_attribution": "product",
      "exception_type": null,
      "source_sql_sha256": [
        "a167a2deb8097ec8df32efbb588895cb4c264b5f1670edd91057a206198b0cfe"
      ],
      "evidence_basis": "Generated SQL omits the authorized source schema. Validation resolves the physical relation to public and denies it under INV-BI-002. The correctly qualified authorized relation exists in the frozen fixture.",
      "server_log_lines": null,
      "score_changed": false,
      "refusal_credit_added": false
    },
    {
      "case_id": "465ef386bdad84f4",
      "evidence_reference": "e5-original-attempt-record:229",
      "original_outcome": "task_error",
      "original_terminal_error_class": null,
      "original_outward_error_class": "sql",
      "original_classification_verified": false,
      "audited_error_class": "permission",
      "audited_cause_category": "generated_missing_schema_qualification",
      "audited_attribution": "product",
      "exception_type": null,
      "source_sql_sha256": [
        "7f1f54061b8688c7a2d19109ab4532aa1e526e9f57c30fe96d897d29e7494996"
      ],
      "evidence_basis": "Generated SQL omits the authorized source schema. Validation resolves the physical relation to public and denies it under INV-BI-002. The correctly qualified authorized relation exists in the frozen fixture.",
      "server_log_lines": null,
      "score_changed": false,
      "refusal_credit_added": false
    }
  ]
}